TFService + git - Pull requests
Visual Studio's current Code Review feature works only from within Visual Studio: https://tfs.visualstudio.com/en-us/learn/code/get-your-code-reviewed-vs
When using TFService with git, we need something similar to Pull Requests, as a means for performing code reviews, as github.com and bitbucket.org offer:
With the latest update of Visual Studio Online, we have added pull requests for git. For the announcement see
TFS Program Manager
Miguel Alho commented
I Agree that this should not be closed. This feature is important in the On-premise version of TFS.
Mert Susur commented
I don't think this issue is only for Visual Studio Online, because I really want to have the same functionality on the TFS on premise installation as well.
Gunnar Magholder commented
It would be great to have this Feature in VS OnPrem as well. Is this so difficult to port? Please please please do it - I want to go back to coding not fighting with a tool that exists solely to help me and my devs.
Vladimir Martynovsky commented
Feature is implemented for VS Online only. Please unmark this as completed as people voted for this feature in VS2013 desktop IDE, not only VS Online.
Shaunt Kojabashian commented
I really need this for TFS server GIT as well.
Thomas Zierer commented
Will pull requests also work with eclipse, i.e. with Team Explorer Everywhere plugin or EGit plugin?
Lori Lamkin commented
we plan on adding in to TFS on prem as well. look for it in a future VS update
Rodolfo Grave commented
Any idea when is this going to be available on the TFServer?
Ewald, I don't think this should be closed. I can't speak for everyone, but I need it for the installed version of TFS. We do not use the TFS online version.
excellent idea, this is very helpful when you work in groups!
Looks like it's not yet rolled out online.
John Barlow commented
This also needs to work outside of Visual Studio through maybe the "TFS 2013's Lightweight Code Comments" interface. Basically, give us a github/bitbucket clone (web based) for doing pull requests/code reviews.
Yes, we need this, urgently.
Yes, this feature is long due. Code review with git / tfs is not an elegant task at the moment.
freddy rios commented
Voted for this, but I wonder if this should be limited to git repositories. I'm not talking of code reviews within teams, but cross team collaborations that pull requests are very good at.
Or maybe TFS already has some alternate approach to this?
Walter Pinson commented
Dude, when is this coming? This feature is sorely needed.
Joberto Diniz commented
git provider does not support code review at all, does it?